Download

How Ben Pickard Hired a Coach with Zero Experience

[00:00:00] Welcome to the Business of Unicorns podcast, where we help gym and studio owners create a business and a life they love. I’m your host, Michael Keeler. Join me and the Business of Unicorns team each week for actionable advice, expert insights, and the inside scoop on what it really takes to level up your gym.

Get ready to unlock your potential and become a real unicorn in the fitness industry

Hello, my friend. Michael here. This is super exciting. Most gym owners know that you need leads to grow your business, and with our brand new BFU Leads engine, you get both paid ads and organic lead generation support and ongoing coaching for only $99 per week. I– You, you didn’t [00:01:00] mishear me. It’s $99 per week.

So if you’re looking to get more leads and more clients, but you’re really kind of sick of doing it on your own and you don’t have an enormous budget, which let’s face it, that’s most of us as gym owners, then click the link below in the show notes. You’ll– What you’ll do is you’ll watch a demo and then claim your absolutely free trial.

Go do it right now. Hello, fitness business nerds. What’s up? Welcome to another episode of the Business Unicorns podcast. I’m here with Ben Pickard. How are you, sir? I am doing great. How about you? Oh my gosh, so good. We haven’t been on a podcast together in a hot minute it feels like. I was just gonna say, it feels like it’s been forever.

I know. Who’s keeping us apart? Who are, who are the powers that be here at Business Unicorns that are not letting us podcast together? It’s probably us. It’s us. We should talk to our employers and see what they- I know. Spoiler alert, we’re the ones that have our meetings go too long or we don’t have time to record.

And so anyway, I’m glad to have you on the podcast with me again, sir. How have you been? I’ve been good. We’re, we’re just saying we’re going through a heat wave right [00:02:00] now, at least when we’re recording this we are. Yes. And both my, as of right now, both my son and my wife are living their best life lounging by the pool.

Wow. It was just my wife, and now my son has emerged from the basement ’cause he just finished grade nine and is enjoying not doing anything this summer. And they are just outside chilling and having fun, and it’s totally great. That’s amazing. That’s amazing. Good for them, and hopefully you get to join them soon when your– whenever your day is over.

It’s too hot for me. Yeah. My wife thrives in this. I’m like inside immediately. That’s so funny ’cause she’s German. You would think that she’d have– she wouldn’t like the heat. She would live on a beach. Wow. Wow. It’s amazing we live in Canada, actually, now that I say it out loud. Yeah. That’s amazing. Yeah.

Well, at the time of this recording as well, we’re having– I’m about to have a heatwave here in New York. It’s gonna be like, I think, over 100 degrees this weekend, and I have a full house. I have 12 family members coming to k- hang out with us this weekend. Wow. So yeah. Not all are staying at our house ’cause we don’t have that many bedrooms, but most of them are.

It’s gonna be really, it’s gonna be [00:03:00] really fun and hot. And so- Yeah … yeah. It’s gonna– but it’s gonna be good. So for all of you listening- I believe it … hope y- hope wherever you are, you’re enjoying summer and getting outside, and enjoying some quality time with people you care about ’cause those are the fun things we do.

Right. Yeah. Let’s dive in, and today’s episode is really inspired by an episode that you did with Pete a little while ago. For those of you who wanna go listen to that episode first, it’s episode 556, and it was called the, what was it called? The State, The State of Hiring and Internships 2026. And you and Pete both talked about internships and hiring, and one of the core points you made in that podcast episode was the idea of hiring for passion and coachability and personality and training for skill.

And we wanted to do a follow-up to that episode because you’ve actually did exactly that recently. So we wanted to chart this real-life case study about someone you hired on your team at your gym, and how you hired someone who had almost no training experience, and, like, how that’s going, what you’re getting from it.

So for all you listeners who are maybe [00:04:00] hiring sometime in, in the future and, or right now, to really think about that paradigm of do you really need people who come with a ton of certs and years of coaching experience, or is there some value in really prioritizing people’s personality, coachability, likability, and training for the rest?

Something worth considering. But let’s dive into your situation, Ben. So walk me through what led to this most recent hire. Yeah, our gym, so we’re in our 13th year. Wow. And a coach who has been with us for a decade, like almost to the day a decade, it was hilarious when I looked back when she started, is no longer with us.

Mm-hmm. That’s a major change. And this is also a coach who had 20 to 30 years of personal training, Aquafit, group training, fitness experience, right? So like a lot. Who was also, to add on top of it, like basically our ideal client. She was 50 plus, had gone through menopause, all the things that align with like what [00:05:00] someone who can relate to middle-aged women, which is our clientele.

And we had someone a week before this coach give their notice that dropped off a resume, which I think is noteworthy nowadays. Yeah. They came in… A human being came into the building unannounced and gave us a piece of paper. Those are things that don’t happen anymore. Amazing. And even in that moment, I’m like, the fact that they did that, we should probably just give them a call and put them on our eventually list, ’cause you never know.

Sure. Yeah. And then a few days later, Pam gave her notice, and we’re like, you know what? We got the job posting up. We got a lot of chaff like you often do, and we interviewed Bobby and yeah, no… You had said that he doesn’t have much personal training experience. I just wanna confirm, this is somebody who has never done a personal training session in their entire life.

Wow. I didn’t know that. Zero. That’s pretty amazing. Yes. Yeah. But they are super enthusiastic. I peppered him with very challenging questions in the second interview. One of the questions like, “Who do you follow? What’s your training?” Et [00:06:00] cetera. The people he named were generally good. The philosophies, the stuff he was doing was like aligned with how I think about things.

Good is the wrong word, is in alignment. Yep. He’s been getting enjoyment from working with his friends and helping some of them. He went through his own weight loss journey, which he can then relate with other clients. He’s not fucking 20. He’s in his 40s, which is huge for our clientele. Yep. He’s making a career change, and get this.

Go– I asked him like, “Why the career change?” Et cetera. He’s like, “I’ve always had jobs that I had to work. Now I’m at a point in my life where I can choose what do I wanna do for work.” He’s like, “I’ve always loved this.” But I wasn’t sure how to go about it, so I got five certifications. Wow. So it’s like, cool, you don’t even know if you’re gonna get a job, but you started with investing time and energy and m- These are all gr- not to say he’s gonna be a great coach, but they’re all green flags for this person- Yeah

is probably interested and wants the thing. Yeah. I’ll just– I’ll say a yes and that, and say those are like neon green flags to me. Right? Those are some- Put some egg lights on them. Yeah. Those are someone… That’s someone who is genuinely [00:07:00] passionate, has personal experience, has life experience, being someone who’s had a previous career, is proactive and professional, showing up, dropping off a resume that’s paper, right?

And, and just the, their ability to invest in themselves and fuel this passion shows how teachable, coachable they are. I can’t, I can’t think of, I can’t think of more important things I’d want on a list of candidates, right? Seriously. Yeah. Yeah. So good. That’s amazing. So I’ve got– When we get to the kinda like takeaways here, one of them is around how we handle the interview process.

Sure. I think we did a great job with that. Again, it’s still early innings, but so far it’s promising. And now we’re on week three. We have a very structured curriculum for onboarding. I don’t think any of the certs are good. Your people are allowed to feel differently. I don’t think any of the certs are good.

I don’t care what certs they have. I still want everyone to go through our thing so that we’re all singing from the same songbook, and I think that’s important from a culture consistency and client experience. Yep. We’re taking him through this, and we’re meeting every week, and we’ve identified he’s good with the [00:08:00] philosophy.

He knows joint by joint approach. He’s familiar with McGill’s work. He– Like all the things, he’s like, “Yep, yep, I’m familiar with that. Had that in my cert. Motivational interviewing is part of what I do. Yep, we talked about this nutrition.” If anything, we’re gonna need to dial it back a bit ’cause our clients are regular people.

Mm-hmm. But we identified the not surprising piece, which is you just need to get reps in, man. You’ve got the theory, you’ve got the application, and we need you to just get out there and cue people, and get some of the cues wrong, and have someone look at you kinda confused, and you’re gonna get better from that.

And if I could teleport myself back 15 years, I was way worse than he was when I started. Sure. I didn’t have any of this shit. Yep. And there’s this piece of if we’re all gonna hire an entry-level coach who’s got three years experience, nobody’s ever gonna get three years experience. And when it’s the right personality and the right person, and he’s eager to learn, and his stuff is submitted on time, and yeah, we had to manage some expectations here and there.

That’s normal onboarding. People miss stuff or whatever. We didn’t [00:09:00] communicate clearly is what actually happened. Here’s someone who is like leaning in at every opportunity and wants to get better, and we’re willing to invest in him because he’s willing to invest in himself with us. Yeah. I think that’s amazing.

I think there’s so many– For me, I just have so many personal kind of takeaways to this example. One is that as I think you have a really generous attitude about the industry at large, which is like some of us as gym owners are gonna have to invest in new people. Probably. If we all want people who have some experience, some of us are gonna have to put in the work and train people who are not yet experienced, right?

And I think that’s a really useful way of thinking about things, right? Is if we want people with three years experience, someone’s gotta give them the first three years, right? And I think that plenty of us out there, I think, are willing and able to do that. And it benefits us, right? I know– I’ll say that a lot of the, in my own experience onboarding people, not just in fitness and gyms, but in all of my jobs, I often had a bigger issue with people that came to a new job with so much experience that I had to [00:10:00] unlearn and undo bad habits or bad thinking or things from previous jobs.

That’s often harder to do than people who are fresh and green and like a sponge. So I think that’s worth flagging. Yeah. The other thing I think is really admirable that you did here, which is you know your avatar being mainly middle-aged women, and I think it would’ve been wrong to bring in a, a really perky, excited, green 18, 20-year-old to come and work with those folks.

Not that– I’m not trying to be ageist here. I’m just saying that folks that are in their 40s, 50s, 60s, beyond How much are they going to be able to relate and hang out with and, and get along with someone who is a fraction of their age? It’s just, I think that the fact that you saw that someone who al- who is closer to their age, closer to their life experience, closer to their own experience of going through their own weight loss journey, right?

That’s someone who’s gonna be really real- able to relate at a deep level to your members. I think that’s a useful [00:11:00] takeaway, too. 100%. I’ll, just one more thing and I promise I’ll shut up. This is great. I had, I, I had a very similar experience when I was a member of, when I lived in San Francisco, I was a member of Crunch Gym.

And Crunch, I don’t know if you all remember this, but when Crunch first opened, and still to this day, they thought of themselves as the sexy, edgy brand. Like the, the location in San Francisco, I remember very vividly, had one of the showers in the locker room had frosted glass. You could see someone from the outside’s silhouette while they were showering, and they thought it was like edgy and sexy, like purple lighting, like just insane.

And, and- Sounds like a privacy violation. It was very densely frosted, right? So it’s just a silhouette. But the idea was like it was like sexy, fun vibes. So because of that, a lot of the staff, at least at a San Francisco location back in, this was the early 2000s, was like young and ripped and sexy and, and all that.

And I was like, “I don’t want a trainer that I’m like intimidated by.” Yeah. “I don’t want a trainer that I want to flirt with.” And, and not that I’m opposed to having an attractive trainer, but it’s like I want someone who [00:12:00] knows their shit and can empathize with my experience of struggling with weight loss and struggling with even wanting to come to the gym.

So I did trial sessions with a few different trainers, and I picked the person who I felt could understand me best. So I picked a, a female who was gorgeous. She was not non-attractive. But she had her own, she had her own… Also not attracted to females, spoiler alert. But she had her own journey. She had lost 150 pounds herself in the previous- Wow

you know, previous 10 years. And I was like, “This is a person that understands what I’m going through, can empathize and relate,” as opposed to the, the naturally gifted and jacked 18-year-old athlete. Was just like- Yeah … I don’t know. Not gonna be, I, I wasn’t gonna vibe as much with them. So anyway, that’s a long-winded way of saying I think you’ve made a lot of wise choices here with this hire.

Thanks. Can you just say a little bit more about, I think the hesitation people have when it comes to hiring people who are a little green on the training floor, is just how much work it’s gonna be to have to get them up to speed. And people often estimate this as being [00:13:00] like, “Oh my gosh, it’s gonna take a year,” and it’s, I don’t know.

Can you just talk about your approach to getting them floor ready? Yeah. So in broad strokes, we, everyone who joins our team does a three-month probationary period. Check your local state laws, not a lawyer disclaimer. But where we are during probation, either the hire- the employer or the employee can end the engagement at any time for any reason.

But after the 90 days, there’s like rules around that. And in the first half of those 90 days, we take them through a very structured onboarding plan that is like how we coach each type of movement, what are the common cues we use, what our coaching philosophy is, what a perfect session looks like. We go through a bit of behavior change.

We use Habit Tree, which is kind of based on motivational interviewing. Whole bunch of shit that we go through in six or seven weeks. Second half of it is them really applying that skill set. So it’s not like… I wanna be clear, we’re not like testing them, but obviously if somebody’s a terrible fit and we made a bad choice, or vice versa, we wanna be able to end the partnership and the agreement there.

And in that time, [00:14:00] we’re also paying them to shadow a lot of sessions. Mm-hmm. I think a lot of these shadowing 20 or 25 sessions a week. Wow. And it starts with, we’ve got a very basic structure of weeks one through week seven. Week one, be everyone’s best friend. Week two is start to give the odd cue here.

Week four, you should be coaching 50% independently, which is arbitrary as hell, but we set expectations around that. Week seven, they should be– we are scheduling them for sessions independently. We want to get them rock and rolling on the floor so they can see, are they organized? Can they do this? Are they good with people?

So it really is a runway to get them up to ready for week seven, and then we’ve got, what? Six weeks after that to decide if this person’s good or not, where we solicit member feedback, we audit sessions. We use the trainer audit playbook. We meet with them regularly, both my GM and me, we meet with them.

I’m acting at the capacity of head coach. She’s acting in capacity of manager. And yeah, we put a lot into people, and I guess the th- the thought here is there was a point where I’m like, so I have a five-year kinesiology degree. I graduated a co-op program. I have [00:15:00] experience in Stu McGill’s labs. I studied the FMS.

I put in a zillion hours. I launched a strength and conditioning program at UWaterloo. I did strength and conditioning club. I was a trainer. I did like all… I’ve actually got a decent resume now that I say it out loud. I should really apply for a job at some point. Actually, I don’t know- I’m so impressed with myself.

Yeah. I haven’t put a resume together in forever. But I used to think that everybody needs to have a CSCS and a kinesiology or human kinetics degree. Yeah. And then I realized that, cool, for some of us are out there are, are doing, we are offering full-time training positions that come with a high five-figure salary with benefits, paid vacation, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.

There are some people doing that, and I think you’re gonna… This might be an exception if you’re in that boat. But if you’re offering a part-time training job where they primarily coach, do a little bit of programming and a little bit of admin, and they’re getting collectively 20 to 25 hours a week, and you’re not paying $75,000 a year, and your bar is three years experience, a human kinetics degree, and a CSCS, your hiring pool is [00:16:00] really small, and they have to live in your local geographic area because nobody’s fly- moving across the country for that.

You’ve got the narrowest hiring pool ever. Yeah. But if I can expand it to people who are checking the box in terms of attitude, and I have decided to bear the burden, for lack of a better way, of teaching the skill, I’ve got a really wide fucking hiring pool. Yeah. I’m honestly surprised we haven’t hired a client at this point.

Mm-hmm. People who like get like- They don’t necessarily get it yet, but they want it and they have capacity. I can– If I can train to get it, that’s a really- Yeah … that’s a lot of potential candidates that I can pull from, and if you’re out there struggling to find a hire, I mean this with love, but like maybe what you’re offering and the standards you’re expecting aren’t in alignment.

Yeah. Yeah. I think that’s often the case, right? I think, I think people really should be considering hiring folks who check all these boxes instead of have a long list of certs, but, but don’t have the personality and the own life experience to go along with it. I [00:17:00] think that’s, I think that’s really important.

And I’ll just, again, from my own personal experience at Mark Fisher Fitness, that was very much our playbook early on. Many of our early hires were people who had almost no fitness experience. Wasn’t BPM a bartender? Yeah, BPM was an actor and bartender. I think almost all of our trainers in the first five years or so were some performer of some kind.

From- Yeah … from theater, musical theater performers, to clowns, to porn stars. They knew how to put on, they knew how to put on a show. And, but we would teach them the rest. And that’s not the right model for everyone, but I think the, the, the principle remains, which is these things that we’re teaching folks, the craft, the art of training, i- is teachable.

But being someone who is excited to learn, being a sponge for continuing education, being like likable and approachable and friendly, being a great team player, being real, a kind of, I’ll use the word professional. What I mean by that is have high integrity and be accountable. Those are skills that are really hard to teach, and those are [00:18:00] things that if…

It’s not if you, it’s not like you have it or you don’t, but it’s just much harder to teach those things than how to say the right coaching cues for a deadlift, right? Yeah. I don’t- You know, I don’t, I, I don’t wanna minimize it, right? It’s not that it’s easy, it’s just it’s easier to teach those skills.

There’s real like kind of black and white, right or wrong things you want people to do on the coaching floor, and the other, those other qualities are a little bit harder to teach if someone doesn’t already have them. What were you gonna add? Part of our philos- my philosophy, and I don’t know if I’m right or not, but I reserve the right to be wrong, that’s for sure.

Yeah. I think you need one coach who knows the why and is like a total nerd about it, and at my gym, that’s me. Sure. Everybody else, like there is an element, I might regret saying this, there is an element of fake it till you make it is okay. Sure. They need to know what to say to avoid people hurting themselves, but if they- Yeah

know the cues and they know the best practice because the person who has all the experience and the knowledge is, “When this happens, use this and this cue,” and 90% of the time that’s gonna work. Yep. They might need to necessarily understand like- [00:19:00] spine and low back biomechanics. Yes. They just need to know, “I need your back to look like this when you deadlift, and here’s what I say to make that happen.”

Yeah. 100%. That is– I genuinely don’t think there’s anything wrong with that. Yes, I would love a gym where every single person is a super functional training science nerd with all this stuff, but like- Sure … I also don’t know if we, if that’s required for success in this. It’s just like we can start them with doing the basics and then my first– your first trainer hire isn’t probably gonna be your performance director.

They’re gonna be the person who works part-time, and you’re the performance director. And there’s an element of one step at a time because that’s how we also learned it. Yeah. That makes sense. It’s, I’m thinking back to when I went to a coaching school, like a conversation on not training coaching, but actual like kind of life business coaching school back in 2012.

They made a really big deal that in your first week of school, you should start coaching people, right? They wanted to start tracking hours of getting hands-on and doing the work even before you even [00:20:00] really knew what you were doing. And the thinking was that getting into a coaching conversation with anyone, just like showing up for a training session, you showing up and like to the gym and moving your body and having someone there to support you and make sure that you’re doing your program is good enough to start, right?

It’s good enough to start. And in coaching school, I started coaching people my fir- the program was like a year long, and in week one I was coaching people. With those sessions, I didn’t charge for them at first, but they got me lots of reps. They helped me learn on my feet what worked and didn’t work. And it also, it proved to me that, that I didn’t n- my expertise was gonna be evolving over time, that I already could be helpful to people on day one because I was trying to be, right?

And same thing with your coaches. Like they might not have all the right cues or all the right information up front, but can they show up and make someone e-enjoy their hour at the gym, make sure they follow the program and not get hurt? Yeah, and that might be good enough for a little while. But the fact that your program gets someone really kind of floor ready [00:21:00] within eight weeks, and then you have another, whatever you said, I think it was the math was another six or so weeks- Yeah

of probationary period for you both to find a groove. That’s pl- that’s plenty of… That, that’s fast enough for most businesses to really be able to train brand new people. Yeah. Yeah, ’cause and there’s, yes, we’re putting a lot, we’re investing a lot, right? It would suck if this didn’t work out. Sure. I don’t wanna pretend we’ve got this made.

He could move to Saudi Arabia. I don’t know. Sure. Shit could happen. Well, the worst that’s gonna happen is we just got another rep of training someone to get better, because we typically hire a coach like every roughly 18 months. Even in 12 years, I don’t actually have that many reps of doing this. Yeah. I have way more reps of almost everything else in my life.

So, I don’t know. I’m willing to put that effort in, and kind of what I mentioned earlier, one of the things I think we did really well, ’cause I’ve talked to a lot of people in Unicorn Society. “This coach checks all the boxes except for this one thing. What do you think I should do about that?” I can’t think of a single time where my answer hasn’t been, “You should ask them about that.”

Now, there are things you’re not supposed to ask in interviews, so [00:22:00] again, not a lawyer. You should not ask the things you’re not allowed to ask, ’cause I did that once and it was super awkward. “How many kids do you have?” And someone was like, “You’re not supposed to ask that.” I’m like, “Oh, I’m sorry. I was just being nice.”

But- Yeah … where it’s like with our guy, it’s like, “Hey, you have no fitness experience. You have five certifications. What’s in this for you?” Yeah. “You’re gonna start at the bottom of a total pool. You’re, you’re gonna make less than all of our other coaches, even though you’re a bit old, bit older than one of them, because you have less experience.

What are you getting out of this?” And it took me a few layers of actual probing before he really opened up and was like, “Here’s what’s going on with me.” Great. I’m like, “Got it. Green flag.” Great. So be willing to ask that thing. If you want someone to work evenings and you’re not sure about their schedule, ask them, “Hey, the job requires this and this.

Is that something you can agree to?” Yeah. And I think by getting that stuff at the gate, which was like, “Dude, we’re gonna be putting a lot of energy into you, and we’re willing to pay you for all of the training, like literally every second, plus free resources, et cetera. But like the trade-off is you’re gonna have to probably work harder than [00:23:00] most of the coaches we hired who already have experience.”

Like- Yeah … “If we’re both on the same page here, I’m happy to move ahead with this. And if we’re not, let’s part as friends.” Yeah. Good for you. It sounds like y’all have a great fit. You have a great fit for now, and I hope it continues. We’ll maybe have you back on the podcast in another few months to maybe do another follow-up here, right?

Because I- If I’m eating my words after probation. Yeah. We’ll see, right? We’ll see. But I think you’re right. Either way, you’re getting great reps at teaching someone, improving your systems for doing that, and honestly putting some goodwill out into the industry by helping develop someone who could be a great asset to another gym at some point, which is also valuable.

But I get the sense that all the fl- all the arrows are pointing in the right direction. This is a good fit for you. Yeah. But I- And it’s saying that I might be wrong about a lot of this. Sure. But I still believe it’s worth pursuing, and that’s meaningful to me. Yeah. Good. Good for you. I think you covered a lot of stuff about your onboarding process, so maybe if all of you wanna hear more about Ben’s specific onboarding process, more about the curriculum and stuff, let us know.

Shoot us an email and let us know if you want us to cover more of that topic. I don’t think we covered that in a while on the podcast. [00:24:00] Either DM us on Instagram or shoot us an email, benormichael@businessunicorns.com. But thanks for a great conversation. Thanks for opening up your gym and sharing this case study.

I think there’s a lot of really positive takeaways. I appreciate that, my friend. Thank you. Happy summer. Yeah. Dear listeners, happy summer. Enjoy your week. We’ll talk soon. Bye. Bye-bye.