Download

How Big Should Your Gym Business Be?

[00:00:00] Welcome to the Business for Unicorns podcast, where we help gym and studio owners create a business and a life they love. I’m your host, Michael Keeler. Join me and the Business for Unicorns team each week for actionable advice, expert insights, and the inside scoop on what it really takes to level up your gym.

Get ready to unlock your potential and become a real unicorn in the fitness industry.

Hello, my friend. Before we jump into today’s conversation, I wanna be sure you’re following our YouTube channel. If you want to add some video content to your diet of practical tips and actionable strategies, you don’t wanna miss out on our YouTube channel. Click the link down below in the show notes or go to markfisheryoutube.com.

And once you’re there, be sure to hit subscribe and hit that bell button [00:01:00] so you never miss an episode

Hello, fitness business nerds. What’s up? Welcome to another episode of the Business of Unicorns podcast. I’m here with Mr. Mark Fisher, and we are coming off the back of our Business of Unicorns Seattle retreat. As of you hearing this, it probably was over a month ago, but as of recording this, we just finished, and I’m so glad we’re recording a podcast.

We can talk a little about it. How are you, Fisher? I am very tired. Yeah. This is a, kind of a crazy stretch for me ’cause I have– I’m speaking at the Ally Conference as of this recording on Friday, so no, no rest for the wicked over here because we– I always try to take that Monday off, and it just, it doesn’t work.

Yeah. And then I have another, do another training next week with our friends at DAXO Exercise. Happy for all these millions of talks that I get to do, but- Yeah … I had a call this morning for a, a keynote for a Pilates convention I’ll be doing in Poland, oddly. Wow. Excitingly. So anyway, a lot, a lot going on over here, so.

We’re not bored. We’re not bored. No, we’re not bored. We’re not. We’re not. Yeah. I feel the same way. We, you know, for those of you who [00:02:00] don’t know, our Unicorns Idea Group you’ve heard us probably mention it a ton, but if you’re newer to the podcast, the Unicorns Idea Group that we have does two big retreats per year.

Two days usually. They, people arrive on a Thursday, and we have all day Friday and a Saturday. We just did it in Seattle. And it’s so much fun, and we get so much out of it. But it also, as you might imagine, is so much energy and so much work. It’s so good to see everyone’s faces, but we leave feeling satisfied and exhausted.

Yeah. And similar, just like you, I had a big presentation with school yesterday. I’m doing a talk for Gary Vaynerchuk’s coaching group this, this Thursday, and then another one next week for another… And so we’re not, we’re not bored over here. But that’s the way we like it, it seems. We design our lives- Sometimes

to be like this. Sometimes I like it. Speaking of having eyes too big for your stomach. Yeah. You wanna introduce today’s topic? Much to talk about. Yeah. Yeah. Certainly one thing that we observed this past weekend, and we’ve verged on this conversation before on the podcast, but we thought it was timely and worth revisiting, is this interesting phenomenon where a lot of people in the [00:03:00] industry, not all, but many, are really starting to scale to multiple locations.

Mm-hmm. And some of them are really starting to have outsized success. We had Chris Travis from Seattle Strength and Performance spoke, who’s on opening up his sixth and soon to be seventh. We have John Farkas, our f- franchise- partner who opened up, I think it was his fourth Aloys, and he has now five gyms.

Six probably will not be too far off. Brittany Cook, who’s now opening up her second location and sold 220 founder’s memberships so far and not opened. So the thing that was interesting about this is on the one hand, oh, it’s so cool. There’s people who are doing really amazing things, and of course, there are many things you can learn from people that are succeeding at that level.

And we’re also just a little curious about what kind of impact this might happen to attendees of this event, what kind of impact it might be happening on the industry writ large, where there’s a, a number of people now that are scaling to three and five locations. And again, to right-size this for listeners, [00:04:00] this is not a large percentage.

I don’t know the exact numbers, but I bet it’s maybe the top few percent. But even if the industry’s large enough, it’s at least tens, maybe more than 100 people now at three locations or more. And I just don’t know that’s actually the right fit for every person based on their- Yeah … values, based on their market, based on their skills, based on how they wanna spend their life.

So we just wanna have a conversation about how one thinks about that. Yeah. I think it’s a, I think it’s a great topic, and I can see– I’m glad we keep returning to it, because I wanna both celebrate the people who are scaling and love the project of scaling, and it fits their life and their goals, and they’re having fun doing it.

Fuck yeah, that, I wanna applaud that. Yes. Standing ovation. And I also wanna make sure that the people who are really stoked about having a single thriving location also know that that’s rad, right? Yeah. Yeah. If you have a single thriving location that gives you, like the, the income you need, the satisfaction and impact [00:05:00] that you want, the work-life balance that is satisfying to you and your family, like also standing ovation.

Fuck yeah. And I’ll say that this is, just zooming out a little bit, I think this is indicative of a challenge I see with a lot of small, mid-sized businesses, is that all too often the people that we have to look up to in books, in movies, in social media are like giant companies, right? The companies that we put on pedestals have- Right

that made the most noise are these giant scaling, often tech companies, who we have very little in common with in terms of how we function and make money. And we think that scale is just part of this giant American dream, and we, we romanticize scaling, and we romanticize giant impact, and we romanticize building huge teams.

And that can be fun and satisfying and rewarding for many people. But when it comes to the brick-and-mortar business of running a gym- There’s a lot of complexity that comes along with that much real estate, that much staff, that much turnover when you have that much staff right? All of that. And so [00:06:00] while that’s amazing, I do think that we’re sometimes missing examples in books, in culture, in coaching groups of people who have one thriving location that is their best life.

And we try to– we certainly eliminate a lot of them on this podcast. We certainly had the bulk of our speakers at all of our retreats are people who have single locations and often love that and have no intentions of growing. But I wanted to– I think we like talking on this podcast to make sure all of you listening don’t feel left behind by hearing those stories.

Yeah. You– And also don’t take the wrong lessons from them because I think- Yeah, yeah … we had this problem a lot at Mark Fisher Fitness where people asked us, “How did you do it? How’d you grow? How’d you do X? How do you do Y? How do you do Z?” Right. And we often had to be like, “Don’t follow us,” right? Yeah. We had a very unique situation of growing very quickly in a crazy market like New York.

Yeah. And so there’s also– it’s very easy to take the wrong lessons from trying to do what these scalers are doing when you’re not in a position of scaling. I, I could keep rambling, but do you wanna jump in and add anything here? Yeah. I think that’s the [00:07:00] two halves of this conversation precisely. Yeah.

It’s like people that feel like they’re failing because they’re not doing it, or people that have really thought through it and they really wanna do it, but potentially aren’t taking the right lessons, particularly from the top operators. Another thing- Mm … that people that listen to the podcast a lot have heard me say before is I think success leaves clues, sure, but survivorship bias rules them all.

It’s the one ring. And so often when you look at the most successful people, they were doing unusual outlier things. And I mean as a compliment, they’re often freaky operators. They’re either in a weird market and/or a weird operator or at a weird opportunity, right? Never been a secret. Mark Fisher Fitness, the opportunity to work with the Broadway community, which happened to be at least a few tens of thousands of people that all worked in a very similar geographic proximity, that all knew each other, that all worked together.

There was really no way to replicate that. That’s how we were able to have the success that we had. And I think [00:08:00] 2015- We did 4 million. It was 11 years ago. Inflation’s been very high. I don’t know what that would be in 2026 dollars, but that’s probably one location doing easily probably $6 million maybe, like 5.5, something like that.

Mm-hmm. So again, that’s not to say there was nothing to learn from us, but in practice, the learning of the wrong lesson is a real thing, and I think we did the longer… I think very quickly we moved to maybe actually, maybe don’t do that, right? But I am very aware that over the years as I have good naturedly, generously shared the answers to people’s questions around how did we do X thing, I am certain there are people that tried to do things that we, A, shouldn’t be doing at all ’cause it was too complicated, right?

Yeah. So we were confusing, is that actually moving the ball forward for even us? And then B, we were only able to pull off because, and again, I don’t wanna sound, this sounds like a brag, but we have unusual operational skills, right? Between you and me, there was a lot of capacity to really wrangle a large a ta- a big [00:09:00] feeling, big personality team, and that worked for us.

But it doesn’t always work. And you know, the, the other half of this I’ll just speak to briefly, which I don’t have a ton to say about other than just naming the phenomenon is the feeling of defeat that can sometimes happen. Yeah. And it’s funny too, and I’m reflecting on this as we sort of process changes we might make for the next retreat.

I don’t wanna oversell this. I think people had a, a great time overall, certainly the feedback has been great. But I did have a sense that maybe there were some people that really their shine was taken off because they’re watching these… And again, the one thing there’s something said for showing gyms that are aspirational, but the results are so bonkers, right?

For so many of the people we brought up there, the things they have done professionally are so superlative, but also so unusual- Yeah … that you might have a phenomenon where someone is making a couple hundred thousand dollars with a facility that’s doing almost a million dollars in a- Yeah … reasonable, affordable market, and they might look at some of those results as far as the numbers, the clients, the location, [00:10:00] the profits, and feel, “Oh man, I suck.

I thought I had a cool thing.” Now I, I, I’m very sensitive to this ’cause I remember this happening to me, not a little bit, a lot, when I went to go see Zingerman’s. Yeah. And I was like, “Oh, I thought I had a cool gym, but I don’t have a cool gym. My gym sucks. They’ve got, they’ve got 37 businesses.” And I’m like in the coffee shop- Yeah

trying not to just be so depressed, ’cause there’s eight people from the staff, got to the coffee shop early to have an impromptu meeting about where we could live out our values better. Yeah. And you’re like, “Oh, man.” I remember you coming back from those being like, “God, we kind of-” Yeah … “suck, don’t we?” And they do a good job.

They really try to tell you, they’re like, “It took us 35 years.” They do a very good job of- Yeah … trying to get in front. And again, I don’t know you can avoid all of that to some extent. Listen, the phone call is coming on the in- from the inside to some. We- I think we need to be able to be- Yeah … expose these and not allow us to feel like we suck.

But even so, there is something to be said for the emotional impact it can have on people that are running businesses that are top 3% in, in the nation, by all accounts are amazing. But are just not as freaky as [00:11:00] some of these businesses, and I just wanna make sure we get that message out too. Which isn’t to say that people shouldn’t aspire, isn’t to say that people shouldn’t learn.

Yeah. But is to say that I don’t want people feeling badly about themselves the way that I know over the years people sometimes looked at MFF and both- Yeah … been inspired, but felt a little defeated. 100%. Let me share a few things I think that I maybe would… I’m recommending to our listeners in terms of what to do about this, right?

Because I think what we’re talking about here is balancing comparing yourself to other, in a, others in a useful way, right? Mm-hmm. We often think of this as benchmarking and really understanding how we fit in the industry. Yep. What our target percentages should be, and I think there’s some amount of benchmarking and comparison that is so productive and so valuable.

And there’s also, we all know the cliché, right, that comparison is the thief of joy, and there’s some kind of comparison that really gets us down and really… And I think that kind of comparison is often missing context, right? So my suggestion, very practical but simple thing, is that when you do [00:12:00] feel inclined to compare yourself to that person you’re following on social media or that speaker at a conference, my, my very basic sug- suggestion to all of you is ask more questions first about the context.

And what I mean by that is by asking why did that work for them and how, right? I, I gave a million examples. I won’t get into a ton of them, but if people asked us about Mark Fisher Fitness and how we would do X, Y, and Z, I find that caveats I would have to give them will re- remember that in year one we had X number of 100 members.

Remember that we also had a million bucks of revenue in year one. Remember that we’re in a city of nine million people in New York City. I had to give them all the context to help them understand why what we did worked for us, and then help them reverse engineer why that probably wouldn’t work for you, unless you’re also in a city of nine million people and have lots of revenue and clients throwing themselves at you without spending any money on marketing, right?

There’s a lot of things that make the conditions unique. Right. So I think asking some questions, doing d- some more probing [00:13:00] when you wanna compare, I think will help you compare real apples into apples instead of apples to donkeys. I think the… Anything you wanna add to that before I keep going? Yeah, I think a, a related spin on that- Yeah

about avoiding compare versus despair is also just asking, do you really want that person’s life? Do you want, like, all the things? Yeah. Yeah. All the things that go along with that person’s life? Yeah. Because here’s a, a, an interesting thing. We’ve obviously done very well over the years, right? It would be disingenuous to pretend that we haven’t, okay?

So acknowledging that. In practice, I don’t know. I look around the industry and I bet there are some people probably with lower overall revenues that are in different kinds of markets and maybe did things like real estate, probably have a bigger net worth than me. And in practice, I’m okay with that ’cause I live in New York City- Yeah

and I go to the best restaurants in the world, and I have an amazing life, and I go to Burning Man. I love my friends. Y- and also you can only eat so many steaks. So I’m personally okay with that because with love, I look at a lot of those lives, I’m [00:14:00] like, “Oh, that’s not what I want. That’s cool that you did that.”

Yeah. And likewise, they– if they were to look at Mark Fisher Fitness or feel maybe some negative comparisons, they probably don’t want my life. Yeah. They probably don’t wanna live in New York. They don’t wanna- Yes … go out to expensive restaurants and cocktails. And it’s so much about what- my life is that I love isn’t the right fit.

Right. So I think that just one more framework- Yes … if you’re finding yourself comparing and despairing is you have to look at the fullness of their life, and almost always in that equation you’ll say, “Oh, I don’t want that. I don’t wanna live there. I don’t wanna live- Yeah … in that house. I don’t wanna do that in my free time.

I don’t want that family situation.” And, and, and that’s fine, right? That’s not about you being better or worse, just about saying that presumably you’ve gotten into your life for a reason. Yeah. It’s funny you went that, that way, ’cause that’s exactly the thing I was gonna add next was, which is I think be- e- before you even allow yourself to do any sort of comparison or benchmarking or looking elsewhere, I think it is important, and maybe I’ll use the framework that we use all the time in Unicorn Study, which we have this three-sided triangle that we talk about a lot, that, that, and the three sides of the triangle are [00:15:00] income, impact, and freedom.

Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Income, impact, and freedom. And I think when it comes to deciding is scaling right for me, what size of business do I really want, I do think it’s helpful to sit down and really do some thinking around the three sides of the triangle. How much income do I need for me and my family to live well wherever we live?

What kind of impact do I care about most? Do I care about building opportunities for my team who works at the gym? Do I care about serving a certain amount of clients? Do I care about opening up my impact to people in my community who are not currently served by other fitness things? What kind of impact do you care about?

Does the impact need to be impacting people every day in the thousands? Or is the dozens okay, right? And I think the freedom part is about the kind of work-life balance. I always use the question for myself when I think about what I want of what do I want my day to look like? Yeah. What’s a day I can find that I would wake up and feel stoked to do?

And for me, that’s about freedom, the freedom and flexibility to spend my days the way that sto- get me excited. And so I just… We’ve talked about the income, [00:16:00] impact, freedom triangle I’m sure on this podcast before, but I think it really applies to this moment- Yeah … where you wanna reflect on what level of scale do I really want, thinking about the money and the impact and the freedom and flexibility that comes with being a founder of a company.

I think those three buckets really help me decide what things I wanna say yes to and what things I wanna say no to. Yeah, I think that’s right. Yeah, ’cause it, it’s interesting even reflecting on my own kind of thinking about as my interests have evolved over the years, right? So I’ve spoken to this before on the podcast.

There was a period last year where I was looking to try and open up a bunch of gyms Mm-hmm … actually. And there were a number of reasons that it wound up not making sense, but one of them is just becoming honest with myself. I just don’t wanna leave my house. I don’t leave my house that much. Yeah. I don’t wanna have to do things that require me to leave my house.

And I already have to do some of it, right? I already have the, a little bit of a stress and a little bit of a commitment because of the one gym I own in Jersey. If I had a lot of gyms, now arguably one could say, okay, if you scale large enough, you can get to the point where [00:17:00] other people need to do those things, and that’s true.

That’s a different kind of freedom, and certainly at least in theory should be, and a different kind of income and impact. But it also is a different kind of risk that you’re taking on. Mm-hmm. A different kind of stress you’re taking on because the stakes are so much higher. There’s so many more things that could go wrong, and a life is very complicated with a lot of leases and a lot of staff.

Potentially some of you are gonna have different service mixes ’cause your second location you’re opening up such and such. You’re also in almost all situations, particularly when you go from one to two, and m- in many situations even three, four, and five, you’re gonna be spending a lot more time in cars.

You’re gonna be driving around a lot. Yeah. The job, you spend a lot more time in spreadsheets than you need to with one. Yeah. Your job just becomes different. And the, again, we keep saying we’re not trying to talk you out of this if that’s what- No … you’re interested by. But it’s just hard to put into words, particularly knowing- What we know now at this, at this late stage of our career, as well as our clients and our kind of extended friend group of people who have done this- Yeah

it just changes. It’s just a [00:18:00] very different thing- Yeah. Yes … and you better be sure- Yeah … because you can’t… It’s not a two-way path, like once you walk through that door. And you- Yeah … and if you walk through that door, you have to… Again, I’m not saying that you can’t successfully be happy with just two locations, but I don’t know.

I don’t know. I think on balance, it’s probably gonna be more likely you- you’re gonna reach a critical mass of three to four to five before you get more of the benefits of the freedom and the income. Yeah. But even then, you’re certainly having more risk at five than you do at two. Yeah. So I don’t know.

It’s- We’re seeing this already … not a full-formed thought here. We see this all the time with the folks we work with. So y- y’all know we have a leadership society group, which is full of entrepreneurs who are like really scaling, and many of them, I think at this point maybe almost all of them are, are…

have or are working on second or third locations. Many are buying commercial buildings. And I won’t share their names. I don’t have permission to share it on the podcast. But someone that’s in our leadership society group, just in our meetup in Seattle, was contemplating a third location, and the main question they wanted to talk about was, “How’s this gonna impact my family?”

Yeah, yeah. I need to go interview my in-laws and my parents and my kids and [00:19:00] see if they’re cool with me spending this time on scaling to this- Mm-hmm … third location. Mm-hmm. And like that’s a real cost, right? Yeah, yeah. Really time away from growing kids and family who… Kids, they change every, every few months.

They’re a whole different human. Yeah. And so you miss those key moments, and that’s something you can’t get back. And I think those are… When we talk about freedom, that’s what we’re talking about, right? Yeah. It’s not just the freedom and flexibility of your schedule. It’s the freedom of your peace of mind.

It’s the freedom to spend quality time with the people that you want to spend quality time with. And I think my invitation to all of you, I think the thing Fisher and I are saying here is, if you’re not clear about where you stand on this, on what your vision is for what kind of scale would be most satisfying to you and your business, especially if you have a business partner and you haven’t had this conversation yet or recently, it’s a really great conversation.

And if it’s helpful to think about the three buckets of income, impact, freedom, and do some writing, brainstorming about it- Yeah … it could be really helpful just to try and get on the same page with your partner. Mm-hmm. Or if just you’re, you’re solo, just with yourself about what, [00:20:00] what success really feels like, what you’ll…

what kind of satisfaction you’re chasing. I, I know we’ve had that conversation about every 18 months, it seems, for- Yeah … for nearly north of 14 years. Yeah. Uh, and every time we have it, it seems like one or both of us have- And it evolves … shifted at least a little- Yeah … what we want. Yeah, yeah. And that’s okay.

I think that’s okay. Yeah. Yeah. Maybe just to start to land the plane here. Please. Probably the last thing I would say is- Some of you should open up five. Yeah, that’s true. Some of you should open up 50. So to be very clear as we talk through this, a- and y- hopefully you’re thinking through this, ’cause again, my hope is if I can talk you out of this, I wanna talk you out of it, right?

But if I can’t, let’s go. Reminds me of like acting class. When I was in acting class, they try to talk you out of it with the understanding that if like, all right, if you’re that stubborn, you’re gonna do it, let’s do it. Let’s put it all in. Yeah. So my, my, my follow-up suggestion is if you’re like, “No, I’ve thought about this and I’m willing to pay this price for this upside for [00:21:00] how…”

‘Cause again, there’s many arguments for it, right? Mm-hmm. Outside of the income, outside of the, the freedom you create, like the way you can impact people, the opportunities for you to grow and develop, which if you’re- Yeah … listening to this podcast, like it’s a very important thing for you, like who you can become in the process, the pursuit of this worthy goal or idea.

My suggestion is then let’s just not put the cart before the horse and do the things that need to be done to get the basics in place. Because the advantage is, again, not trying to say you should do it, but the good news is it’s, I don’t wanna say easier than it’s ever been. There’s more knowledge than there’s ever been, right?

Like e- even take working with a company like Business for Unicorns, right? If you join the Unicorn Society, so if you join the uni- the Leadership Society- I don’t know the percentage of our membership base with two or more locations now, but, like, it’s beefy. And a lot of our coaches- It’s growing … right?

You look at- Yeah … like, the Chris Travises, the John Farkases, the Brittany Cooks, the three we happen to have mentioned. You know, these people are doing it at, as a high a level as far as the execution, profitability, and they’d be the first to tell you, like, it’s not easy per [00:22:00] se. But what I can tell you is, like, they’re, most days, I think, are very happy with it and it really was the right call.

They’re doing some super impressive stuff. So if you- Yeah … do think that makes sense to do it, at the risk of sounding like a shill for our organization, maybe it doesn’t need to be us. There’s obviously other people. But I would highly encourage you, rather than trying to make your own mistakes at that kind of level- Yeah

you’re just, the precipice is, you’re so much higher that if things go bad, they can go so much worse. I would really urge you, make sure the basics of blocking and tackling are in place, that you’ve really dialed in all the boring biz op stuff we talk about all the time, and try to get around, make connections with the people in the industry that are at the, the farthest most reaches of the fitness industry universe, ’cause they are doing amazing things, and I think we are really discovering some models, and people are figuring out some stuff that would be good for you to know if you’re gonna try to open up 10.

Yeah, 100%. We talked about this in Seattle a little bit. We’re still in a pretty young industry, and we’re at the point now where I think because of the age of the industry, technology advancing as it has, we’re seeing a lot more people [00:23:00] scale than we did before. Even in a, a economy that has some serious headwinds- Yeah

we’re still seeing more scale than we did certainly even five, 10 years ago. Yeah. And so if you’re on the path to scale, go for it. Fucking do it. And as Fisher said, the risks just get a little greater, so having some help and support- Yeah … again, whether it’s us or someone else, becomes really meaningful.

And there’s a lot of people who’ve figured some shit out, so- Mm … find them and- Yes … and learn from them. Yeah. I think that’s a great thing, great- Yeah … sentiment to end on. Awesome. Thanks, Fisher. This was a fun chat. I’m sure this is a topic we’re gonna return to again someday. But thanks for listening, everyone.

Hope this was valuable. Go have a kickass week, and we’ll talk to you on the next one. Bye, Fisher. [00:24:00] Bye.